REVIEW OF CURRENT RESEARCH ON THE CORROSIVE EFFECTS OF FOAM CONCENTRATES AND THEIR WORKING SOLUTIONS ON FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEM COMPONENTS
Abstract
Problem statement. The problem of corrosion caused by aqueous firefighting agents remains highly relevant in the field of fire safety. When foam concentrates are used in fixed and autonomous fire suppression systems, metallic components (tanks, pipelines, nozzles, valves, sprinklers, etc.) are exposed to aggressive chemical interactions. Numerous studies have demonstrated that contact between foam solutions and metal surfaces initiates chemical reactions that form corrosion products, which in turn reduce equipment reliability and may even lead to system failure. Objective. This study aims to analyze recent research on the corrosive activity of foam concentrates and their working solutions on autonomous and fixed fire suppression systems, and to identify strategies to mitigate the harmful effects of corrosion, thereby improving the fire protection of facilities. Description of the material. The main experimental methods for assessing the corrosive activity of foam concentrates include immersing steel plates into foam working solutions followed by measuring mass loss. In addition to the gravimetric method, electrochemical analysis is employed to determine corrosion potential and corrosion current density. This approach enables a quantitative comparison of the corrosiveness of different types of foam concentrates. Notably, protein-based foams (including fluoroprotein foams) have shown the highest levels of corrosive activity in experimental conditions. In contrast, synthetic foams that include specialized stabilizers and corrosion inhibitors generally demonstrate lower corrosive effects. To reduce the corrosive impact of aqueous firefighting agents, a multi-faceted approach is recommended. First, corrosion-resistant materials should be used, avoiding unprotected carbon steel and zinc. It is common practice to protect the internal surfaces of tanks and fire extinguisher bodies with paints or polymer coatings. Second, corrosion inhibitors should be incorporated directly into the foam concentrate formulations. Third, water quality should be controlled by using softened or demineralized water to prepare working solutions, thereby avoiding salts and contaminants that increase electrical conductivity. Fourth, after fire suppression activities, systems should be promptly cleaned to remove residual foam and corrosion products. The international NFPA standard states that protein-based foam concentrates must include corrosion inhibitors, and that system components (e.g., piping, valves) must be made from materials compatible with the foam concentrate, such as brass, bronze, or stainless steel. For synthetic foams, material compatibility must be explicitly stated. Additionally, the standard regulates water supply conditions: the water used must be compatible with the foam concentrate and must not contain suspended particles or salts that could accelerate corrosion. Regarding Ukrainian standards, DSTU EN 1568 does not provide specific requirements regarding the corrosive properties of foam concentrates. This issue is mainly addressed in the manufacturer’s technical documentation, rather than being officially regulated with mandatory labeling. Another Ukrainian regulatory document, DSTU 3789:2015, requires that general-purpose foam concentrates exhibit low corrosive activity. Conclusions. Current practice indicates that the design and operation of fire suppression systems must take into account the corrosive effects of firefighting agents on system components, and operational guidelines must be defined accordingly. The analysis suggests that the most straightforward and cost-effective method of mitigating corrosion is the inclusion of corrosion inhibitors in foam concentrate formulations. However, further research is needed to evaluate the fire-extinguishing performance of such enhanced compositions. It is also necessary to revise regulatory documents concerning corrosion prevention in fire suppression systems, particularly regarding the use of protective paint or polymer coatings on the internal surfaces of fire extinguisher bodies.
Downloads
References
2. Patrascu M. T., Busuioc A. D., Busuioc C. Experimental study on the corrosion of carbon steel and aluminum alloy in firefighting protein foam concentrates. Materials. 2021. Vol. 14. No. 23. Article No. 7259. DOI: 10.3390/ma14237259
3. Revie R. W., Uhlig H. H. Corrosion and corrosion control: An introduction to corrosion science and engineering. New Jersey: Wiley-Interscience, a John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Publication, 2008.
4. Bertschy A. V., Peterson H. B. Corrosion resistance of some common metals to concentrated and 6 % solutions of light water fire-extinguishing agent. NRL Report No. 6932. Naval Research Laboratory, 1969.
5. Scheffey J. L., Wright J. A. Analysis of test criteria for specifying foam firefighting agents for aircraft rescue and firefighting: Appendix A. Report No. DOT/FAA/CT-94/04. FAA Technical Center, 1994. URL: https://www.fire.tc.faa.gov/pdf/ct94-04.pdf
6. Su P., Fuller D. B. Corrosion and corrosion mitigation in fire protection systems. Research Technical Report No. 0003040794. FM Global, 2014. URL: https://atossa.fr/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/ FMCorrosionTechReport.pdf
7. Radwan K., Rakowska J., Ślosorz Z. Impact of surfactants used in extinguishing agent to corrosiveness of firefighting equipment. In: Ali M., Platko P. (Eds.). Advances and Trends in Engineering Sciences and Technologies. CRC Press/Balkema. 2015. P. 159–164. DOI: 10.1201/b19249-31
8. Kaiser L. The growing problem of corrosion in preaction sprinkler systems. ORR Protection, 2013. URL: https://www.orrprotection.com/mcfp/problemof- corrosion-in-preaction-sprinkler-systems (дата звернення: 24.05.2025).
9. Войтович Т. М., Ковалишин В. В., Войтович О. Б. Дослідження впливу карбозоліну та оксиетилідендифосфонової кислоти на корозійну активність робочих розчинів піноутворювачів. Пожежна безпека. 2023. № 43. С. 41–49. DOI: 10.32447/20786662.43.2023.06
10. Carpen L., Ohligschläger T. A case study on corrosion of stainless steel in firewater mains. Proceedings of the 6th European Stainless-Steel Conference – Science and Market. Helsinki, Finland, 10–13 June 2008. P. 129–135.
11. Tihen, J. Corrosion inhibition of dry and preaction fire suppression systems using nitrogen gas. St. Louis: Potter Electric Signal Company, LLC.
12. Ryan Fireprotection Inc. The solution for corrosion in a fire sprinkler system. 2014. URL: https://www.ryanfp.com/solution-for-corrosion (дата звернення: 24.05.2025).
13. FM Global. Corrosion in automatic sprinkler systems. In: FM Global property loss prevention data sheets 2-1. 2016. P. 1–19. URL: https://unitedfiresystems.net/wp-content/ uploads/2018/11/01-Loss-Prevention-Data-Sheet-2-1- Corrosion-in-Automatic-Sprinkler-Systems-FMGlobal- Oct-20161.pdf
14. Merwin J. Corrosion in fire sprinkler systems: Increasing your liability, increasing your costs, and shortening system life. Potter/Corrosion Solutions, 2016. P. 1–5. URL: http://www.ifma-afc.org/docs/submissions/ 20160718_AFC_PotterCorrosionSolutions.pdf
15. O’Connor J. Inhibiting sprinkler pipe corrosion with nitrogen generation technology. International Fire Protection. 2017. P. 98–100.
16. Knurek M. The problem of corrosion in metal fire sprinkler systems. Gulf Fire. 2017. Vol. 5. URL: https://gulffire.com/the-problem-of-corrosionin- metal-fire-sprinkler-systems (дата звернення: 24.05.2025).
17. Broadley, S. Corrosion in fire sprinkler systems. St. Louis: Potter Electric Signal Company, 2017. URL: https://www.scribd.com/document/633285794/ stephen-broadley-potter-electric-signal-company-pdf
18. Hopkins, M. An introduction to corrosion in sprinkler systems: Its identification and mitigation. Anne Arundel, MD: National Fire Sprinkler Association, 2018.
19. Quick Response Fire Supply. № 223 – Fire sprinkler system pipe material: NFPA requirements and the pros and cons of steel. QRFS, 2019. URL: https://www.qrfs.com/blog/223-fire-sprinklersystem- pipe-material-nfpa-requirements-and-the-prosand- cons-of-steel (дата звернення: 24.05.2025).
20. Su P., Doerr W. W. Fire protection sprinkler system for extremely corrosive industrial duct environments. Process Safety Progress. 2010. Vol. 29. No. 1. P. 70–78. DOI: 10.1002/prs.10319
21. Su P., Tatar F. W., Chivukula S., Doerr W. W. Weld seam corrosion of steel sprinkler pipe. Presented at CORROSION 2013, NACE International Conference, Orlando, FL, USA. March 2013. Paper No. 2140.
22. Su P., Fuller D. B. Steel piping material corrosion: Dry and pre-action fire protection systems. Sprinkler Age. 2013. Vol. 32. No. 5. P. 22–26.
23. Su P., Chivukula S., Tatar F. W., Swinnerton B. Corrosion of sprinkler piping under compressed nitrogen and air supervision. Presented at CORROSION 2015, NACE International Conference, Dallas, TX, USA. March 2015. Paper No. 5548.
24. Carpén L. Corrosion of stainless steel in fire protection systems. VTT Research Report No. VTT-R-01556-08. VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, 2008. URL: https://publications.vtt.fi/ julkaisut/muut/2008/PALOMICTutk_rap_final.pdf
25. Elahresh N., Jewilli F. Evaluation of fire extinguishing foam concentrate for 304 stainless steel. Presented at the 4th International Technology of Oil and Gas Conference (TOG 2008), Tripoli, Libya, October 2008. Paper No. TOG-78.
26. Войтович Т. М., Ковалишин В. В., Кошеленко В. В. Дослідження впливу інгібіторів корозії на корозійну активність робочих розчинів піноутворювачів. Пожежна безпека. 2017. № 30. С. 16–21.
27. Wood, Ramboll, COWI. The use of PFAS and fluorine-free alternatives in fire-fighting foams – Final report. European Commission DG Environment & European Chemicals Agency, 2020. URL: https://echa.europa.eu/ documents/10162/28801697/pfas_flourine-free_ alternatives_fire_fighting_en.pdf/d5b24e2a-d027-0168- cdd8-f723c675fa98
28. Rakowska J., Ślosorz Z. Corrosion of fire extinguishing systems and firefighting fittings. Safety & Fire Technology. 2011. Vol. 24. No. 2. P. 113–120.
29. Radwan K., Rakowska J., Ślosorz Z. Corrosion of firefighting equipment caused by surfactants used in extinguishing agent. In: Al Ali M., Platko P. (Eds.). Advances and Trends in Engineering Sciences and Technologies: Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering Sciences and Technologies (ESaT 2015), Tatranska Strba, High Tatras Mountains, Slovakia, 27–29 May 2015. CRC Press/Balkema, 2015. P. 159–164.
30. ДСТУ 3734-98. Вогнегасники пересувні. Загальні технічні вимоги. Київ: Держспоживстандарт України, 1998.
31. NFPA 16: Standard for the Installation of Foam- Water Sprinkler and Foam-Water Spray Systems. 2014 ed. Quincy, MA: National Fire Protection Association, 2014.
32. ДСТУ 3789-98. Піноутворювачі загального призначення для гасіння пожеж. Загальні технічні вимоги і методи випробувань. Київ : Держспоживстандарт України, 1998.
33. ДСТУ EN 1568:2018 (усі частини) Вогнегасні речовини. Піноутворювачі Київ: Міністерство розвитку економіки, торгівлі та сільського господарства України, 2018.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Copyrights CC-BY





